Does Your Phone Hurt Your Focus? What the Research Says

Does a phone nearby hurt focus? Early studies said yes, replications often found nothing, and notifications have clearer evidence. Here is the research.

As of November 2026, the evidence that a phone sitting near you, silent and untouched, lowers your focus is mixed. The original 2017 “brain drain” experiments found that performance was worst with the phone on the desk and best with it in another room, but several pre-registered replications found no difference, and a 2023 meta-analysis of 56 comparisons found a pooled effect only for working memory. Phones that actively notify you have a clearer record of interrupting attention. The main caveat is that most studies are short laboratory tasks with students, so they say little about a full working day.

This page collects the studies with links and will be updated as new ones appear. For what to do about it in practice, see reset your phone’s defaults in 30 minutes.

Key findings at a glance

  • A phone that alerts you disrupts a concurrent attention task. In one experiment, a call or text during the task was followed by more errors than no notification (Stothart et al., 2015).
  • The “mere presence” effect was reported first, then often not replicated. Early studies found lower performance with a phone nearby (Thornton et al., 2014; Ward et al., 2017), while a pre-registered direct replication of Ward’s second experiment found no difference (Ruiz Pardo and Minda, 2022).
  • A meta-analysis found a limited effect. Across 56 comparisons and 7,093 participants, only working memory capacity showed a statistically significant pooled effect; the other cognitive functions did not (Parry, 2023).
  • Individual differences may matter. Whether the phone was appealing or the person was dependent on it changed the pattern in some studies, though not always in the same direction (Ito and Kawahara, 2017; Hartmann et al., 2020).
  • Methods vary a lot and many studies are small. The meta-analysis reported substantial methodological heterogeneity and generally poor statistical power (Parry, 2023).

Phones that notify you

Stothart, Mitchum and Yehnert (2015)

Participants did a sustained attention task. They were randomly assigned to receive a phone call, a text message, or no notification during it, and the researchers sent the alerts to the participants’ own phones.

What they found: Participants who received a call or text made more errors than the no-notification group, and the authors describe the disruption as similar in size to actively using the phone.

Limits: It was a short laboratory task and it did not involve real work or driving. A notification is also a different thing from a phone that is simply nearby.

The “mere presence” studies

Thornton, Faires, Robbins and Rollins (2014)

Two studies tested whether a cell phone in the room, not in use, reduced task performance.

What they found: The authors report that mere presence may be distracting enough to reduce attention and performance, especially on tasks with greater attentional and cognitive demands.

Limits: Their own abstract says “may be”, and the studies are small laboratory experiments. See the replications below for how later work compares.

Ward, Duke, Gneezy and Bos (2017)

This is the study behind most “keep your phone in another room” headlines. Across two experiments with nearly 800 undergraduates (a figure from the authors’ university press office), participants did tasks measuring working memory capacity and fluid intelligence with their phones silenced. The phone was face down on the desk, in a pocket or bag, or in another room. In the second experiment the phones were also switched off.

What they found: Performance followed a pattern: lowest with the phone on the desk and highest with it in another room. The cost was greatest for people who scored highest on smartphone dependence.

Limits: These are student participants on short tasks. The effect was reported as an average difference between groups, not as a certainty for any one person.

Ito and Kawahara (2017)

Participants did a visual search task with either a mobile phone or a notepad beside the screen, and answered a questionnaire about internet use and attachment.

What they found: The mere presence effect appeared in participants with low questionnaire scores, but not in those with high scores, who instead found targets faster on the side of the phone. The authors suggest the effect depends on how appealing the device is to the person.

Limits: A single task and a narrow visual-search setting.

Replications and reviews

Hartmann, Martarelli, Reber and Rothen (2020)

The researchers compared a phone present on the desk with a phone absent, using short-term memory and prospective memory tasks, and measured smartphone dependence and impulsiveness.

What they found: No overall effect of phone presence on either memory function. For prospective memory, people with low smartphone dependence did better when the phone was absent.

Limits: They tested memory tasks, not the working memory tasks of the original study, so this is not a like-for-like replication.

Ruiz Pardo and Minda (2022)

This was a pre-registered direct replication of the second Ward experiment. Phone location (on the desk, in a pocket or bag, or outside the room) and phone power (on or off) gave six conditions. Participants did an operation span task and a go/no-go task.

What they found: The brain drain effect did not replicate. There was no difference between location conditions on either task, and the authors conclude that mere presence may not be enough to affect cognitive performance.

Limits: One replication, with its own sample, cannot settle the question. It does show the original result is not reliable enough to treat as established.

Skowronek, Seifert and Lindberg (2023)

Adults aged 20 to 34 did a concentration and attention test with and without a smartphone present.

What they found: Performance was lower when a smartphone was present, which the authors read as support for the idea that the device uses up limited cognitive resources.

Limits: It is a single experiment, and the evidence overall remains split.

Parry (2023)

A systematic review and six meta-analyses (56 comparisons, 7,093 participants) of the brain drain hypothesis.

What they found: Only working memory capacity was negatively affected by mere presence. The other cognitive functions produced null summary effects. The author describes this as limited support for a smaller effect than first theorised, and says that methodological concerns limit how far the literature can support or refute the hypothesis. A preprint version appeared on PsyArXiv in 2022; the cited version is the peer-reviewed journal paper.

Limits: Heterogeneous methods and low statistical power in the underlying studies.

Wilmer, Sherman and Chein (2017)

A narrative review of research on smartphone habits and cognition, covering attention, memory and delay of gratification.

What they found: The authors describe the research area as intensifying but still limited, and say that in some domains the literature is not yet mature enough to support firm conclusions.

Limits: It predates the replications and the meta-analysis above.

What the research doesn’t tell us yet

  • Whether any effect lasts across a real working day. Nearly all the studies are brief laboratory tasks.
  • Whether results from mostly student samples apply to other adults, or to people with ADHD, who are rarely studied separately in this literature.
  • Which version of “presence” matters: face down, on silent, switched off, in a bag or in another room. Studies differ in how they set this up.
  • Whether the effect, where it exists, comes from the phone itself or from what it means to the person, such as expecting a message.
  • Whether removing the phone improves long-term focus or only short-term task scores. The trials above did not test that.

What this means if you want to try it

You do not need the brain drain effect to be real for a lower-friction phone to be worth trying. Notifications have the clearer evidence, and they are the easiest thing to change.

This is general information, not medical advice. If trouble focusing is affecting your work, study or daily life, a doctor or other qualified professional can help.

Common questions

Does having my phone on my desk reduce my focus?

Possibly, in some situations. Early studies said yes, a pre-registered replication found no difference, and the 2023 meta-analysis found an effect only for working memory. The evidence does not support a firm answer either way.

Is it better to put my phone in another room?

There is no strong evidence that it helps everyone. It does remove notifications and the temptation to pick the phone up, which is a reasonable thing to try for demanding work.

Does it matter if my phone is face down or switched off?

The original authors tested phones on the desk and switched off, and reported the pattern held, but a replication with both conditions found no effect at all, so this remains unclear.

Do phone notifications hurt focus?

One experiment found that receiving a call or text during an attention task led to more errors than no notification. It was a short laboratory task, so treat it as suggestive for everyday work.

Does this apply to people with ADHD?

The studies above did not test people with ADHD separately, so we cannot say. Reducing interruptions is a reasonable thing to try, and a qualified professional can advise on your own situation.

Sources